Your Guide to the Best Pizza in Times Square: Slices Worth Ditching Broadway For

Step into Times Square yeah, that buzzing heart of NYC and you just know you’re smack in the middle of it all. Neon everywhere. The whoosh of taxis. Throngs of, well, everyone. But let’s get real: after fifteen minutes dodging selfie sticks or getting lost in the glowing billboards… you NEED food. And not just any food. If you’re like me, you want the best pizza in Times Square. The slice you clutch while balancing shopping bags, your MetroCard, and just a hint of rain in the air. It’s a Big Apple rite of passage.

I’ll be honest. I’ve stumbled into my share of pizzerias hoping for a bite worthy of a “Dear Diary” entry but wound up with cardboard crust. So, here’s my deal with you: this guide goes beyond the bland and mediocre. It’s a pizza treasure map. I’ll spill where to go for that classic, foldable slice so gooey you need three napkins…and I’ll point you toward a few wild cards if “classic” just isn’t your jam.

Ever get overwhelmed by choice? I’ve been therestaring at slices spinning behind glass, frozen by indecision (and hunger). We’re skipping pizza paralysis today. Whether you’re craving pepperoni so spicy it’ll make you sweat, or you need vegan cheese that actually tastes like cheese, you’re covered. I’ll sprinkle in some stories: like the time I almost dropped a slice while dodging a Spider Man impersonator (true story) or the spot where locals brush shoulders with starry eyed tourists.

Ready to bite in? Lace up, loosen your belt, and let’s take a cheesy, saucy stroll through the best pizza Times Square serves up. And heyif you’ve ever wondered if you can really grab a “New York slice” in the middle of all that chaos, get comfy. You’re about to find out.

• New York Night: Your Guide to the City’s Wildest Views, Surprises, and After-Dark Adventures

Best pizza in Times Square

Hunting down the best pizza in Times Square? You’re juggling neon overload, TikTokers playing Frogger in crosswalks, andlet’s be reala lot of so so slices staring back at you from behind greasy glass. Pull up a chair. You’re about to get the lowdown on where pizza dreams actually come trueno FOMO, no regrets, just pure cheesy bliss.

Mama’s Too

Let’s talk about square pizza because at Mama’s Too, they take this humble shape and give it divine purpose. Imagine thick, almost focaccia like doughcrispy edges with the kind of caramelization that makes you hit rewind in your mind. Toppings here? A wild ride. On my last visit, the elote slice (yes, corn on pizza!), left me beaming like a dad at graduation. If that’s too out there, the cacio e pepe and the vodka slice will remind you that simple done right smacks harder than any TikTok dance challenge. Also, be warned: the pies go fast. If you wander in late, you might get that “last slice blues”it’s that popular. Their West Village shop gets busy too, but for a true Times Square pizza legend, this spot absolutely pulls rank.

Ops

Okay, so Bushwick is a Brooklyn hop away, but sometimes you crave that Neapolitan vibepillowy sourdough crust with toppings that read like an artist’s palette. Ops is where you take visiting friends when they say, “No, seriously, what’s your favorite?” Order a pie with potatoes, ricotta, and broccoli rabe or roll the dice with oyster mushrooms, guanciale, and truffle y toppings. The dough here is so tangy and light that you might forget to share. And if you’re paralyzed by the natural wine wallrelax, that’s half the fun. Newbies, ask for something “funky but not too funky” and you’ll fit right in.

Best Pizza

Let’s set the scene. You’re craving pizza that’s got neighborhood roots but tastes like it’s seen the world. Best Pizza in Williamsburg is your place. No frills, open late, and legendary for the White Piericotta, mozzarella, pecorino, and that finish of caramelized onion and parsley. Here’s the kicker: the crust has sesame seeds baked right in. It’s a little surprisenutty, toasty, and totally addictive. You step outside with a grease stained paper plate and suddenly the chaos of Times Square feels distant, like you’ve been let in on a secret the locals keep close.

Una Pizza Napoletana

Ever taste something so good you had to close your eyes for a second? That’s Una Pizza Napoletana. Anthony Mangieri’s pies are nothing short of a love letter to Naples. The dougha slow rise dream. Each pizza is a fleeting masterpiece, with Mangieri personally pressing, stretching, and slinging until he runs out. It’s like a pizza version of Willy Wonka’s Golden Ticketshow up early, take what you can get, and savor every molten cheese bite. If you see a bottle or two of natural wine, it’s worth grabbingthis place does small things very right.

Paulie Gee’s

Signature pies with attitude and cult statusthat’s Paulie Gee’s. I still remember my first “Hellboy” slice, with peppy hot honey and pepperoni that crisp into little cups. The bottom is dusted with sesame, the sauce is tangy, and the cheese stretches in perfect strands. On days when you want a break from ordinary margherita monotony, order “The Mootz”it’s mozzarella, garlic, pecorino, and pure comfort. Don’t be weirded out by honey on pizza. Try it once, and suddenly, spicy sweet is the new normal.

Roberta’s

If you’re the type who thinks “dive y” is a design aesthetic, Roberta’s Bushwick shrine was made for your Instagram feed. Picture walls covered in stickers and graffiti, loud rock and roll on the speakers… and then, in walks the “Bee Sting” pizza: soppressata, mozzarella, a hit of hot honey. Eat it with natural wine and laughter with strangers at communal tables. Once you’ve braved the line, hang in the big backyardsummer in New York, a slice in hand, chaos on pause. That’s the kind of memory you’ll replay on rainy days.

Prince Street Pizza

Oh, Prince Street. If you’ve seen pizza on your feed with those perfect pepperoni cupsthis is the place. The line is part of the experience, with everyone from tourists to locals pretending not to be starstruck by the celeb photos wallpapered inside. The move here is the Sicilian slice: thick, pillowy base, cheese under sauce (so the dough doesn’t get soggygenius), and those little ‘roni cups hanging onto every drop of oil like it’s liquid gold. Honestly, it’s a rite of passage for anyone claiming to have eaten the best pizza in Times Square.

Leo

Sometimes all you want is pizza and a vibe, no attitudejust comforting sourdough crusts, a quality cheese pull, and some creative twists. Leo in Williamsburg is that friend who always nails movie night snacks. Their “Papa Madre” is a personal favoritepotato and fontina cheese, creamy and brightened up with lemon and oregano. Don’t skip their focaccia (or the soft serve for dessert, rotating with the seasons). You want Brooklyn flavor without the scene? Leo keeps it real.

F&F Pizzeria

The first time I tried F&F’s clam pie, I had that “wait, are we in Italy?” moment. Thin crust, loaded with bright garlic, real pieces of clam, a hit of lemonthink garlic bread meets summer at the beach. Each slice is reheated to order, so no limp or gooey disasters. Carb lovers: the cacio e pepe slice is a solid move. If you’re feeling adventurous, chart your own slice tourF&F does not disappoint.

L’Industrie Pizzeria

Craving that snappy, almost crackery crunch? L’Industrie is the move. The pizza here is so thin you can almost see through it, but the flavor is all inthe caramelized edge, the gooey burrata topping, or if you’re feeling wild, fig jam and bacon. I watched a couple split slices while eyeing the pastry casefilled with cream buns and Italian doughnuts (because why not finish with dessert?). No sog, no sad folds. Just solid pizza, every single time.

Scarr’s Pizza

Let’s finish strong with an old school classic. Scarr’s gives off big time vintage New York vibesthink no nonsense counter, endless foot traffic until 1 a.m., and slices that taste a little extra…because they mill their own flour. Grab a Hotboi if you love spicy (jalapeños and hot honey). Or play it safe with a classic cheese that’s anything but basic. Tip: the crust here tastes like no other, all brown butter and wheatif you know, you know.

Whew. So many slices, so little time. If you love surprises, pizza with edge, or you’re just hunting for your next “best pizza in Times Square” moment, you’re officially set. Now, go treat yourselfyour taste buds will thank you, and hey, snap a pic for your brag reel.

• Glacier National Park Camping Guide: 7 Must Know Tips for Unforgettable Trips

Frequently Asked Questions

Where can I find the best pizza near Times Square?

You can find some of the best pizza near Times Square at spots like Prince Street Pizza for their famous Sicilian slices, Mama’s Too for unique square pizzas, and Joe’s Pizza for classic New York slices. Each offers a memorable experience and authentic flavors.

What types of pizza are popular in Times Square?

In Times Square, you’ll find a mix of classic New York style thin slices, Sicilian squares, and unique pies with creative toppings, like cacio e pepe or spicy honey. There’s something for everyone, from traditional to adventurous tastes.

Are there any unique pizza toppings to try in Times Square?

Yes! Many pizzerias in Times Square offer unique toppings. For example, Mama’s Too features elote (Mexican street corn) and cacio e pepe, while Roberta’s is known for their “Bee Sting” with spicy honey and pepperoni.

Can I get Neapolitan style pizza near Times Square?

Absolutely. Places like Ops and Una Pizza Napoletana serve Neapolitan style pizzas close to Times Square, offering pillowy dough, fresh mozzarella, and creative, high quality toppings.

Which pizzeria is best for a classic New York slice?

For a true classic New York slice, Joe’s Pizza and Prince Street Pizza are popular local favorites. Their thin, foldable slices are perfect for the on the go Times Square experience.

Are there any pizza spots with a casual, relaxed vibe?

Yes! Leo and Roberta’s are known for their relaxed environments, making them great places to enjoy delicious pizza without the Times Square hustle.

Is vegetarian or vegan pizza available in Times Square?

Many Times Square pizzerias provide excellent vegetarian options, with plenty of cheese, veggie toppings, and inventive plant based pizzas. Some, like Paulie Gee’s, even offer vegan pies.

Do these pizzerias offer takeaway or delivery?

Most top pizza spots near Times Square offer takeaway, and many also provide delivery services, making it easy to enjoy your favorite slice wherever you are.

Can I find gluten free pizza near Times Square?

Several pizzerias in and around Times Square offer gluten free options. It’s always best to call ahead to check their latest menu for gluten free choices.

Is there late night pizza in Times Square?

Yes! Times Square is known for its late night dining, and many pizzerias stay open late, perfect for grabbing a slice after exploring the city’s vibrant nightlife.