Skip to Content

12 Best Islamorada Resorts, Florida (2024) With Reviews

The Village of Islamorada is located in the Florida Keys.

Are you wondering if you should visit Islamorada?

During a trip to Islamorada, you will find a multitude of fun activities and relaxing environments, such as snorkeling the world-renowned coral reefs, swimming with dolphins, and visiting state parks, plus white sandy beaches and breathtaking sunset views.

Looking for the perfect getaway? Take a look at some of the best island resorts in the world!

Additionally, Islamorada offers superb resorts that are diverse and welcome everyone, from families and friends to couples seeking a romantic excursion.

Planning to stay in Florida? Here is a list of the best all inclusive resorts & hotels in Florida and resorts in Florida on the beach for you to explore.

Find the perfect spot for your getaway by perusing the list below of the best Islamorada Resorts and start dreaming of a once-in-a-lifetime experience.

1. Casa Morada

Casa Morada, Islamorada
@Casa Morada

Rating: 4.5★

Hotel class rating: 3-star

Address: 136 Madeira Road, Islamorada, FL 33036

  • Pet-friendly
  • Picnic area
  • Bar & lounge

Why you should go: During your stay at Casa Morada, you will be immersed in a quiet and intimate atmosphere.

The small boutique resort offers thoughtful amenities as well as entertaining activities.

Amenities and things to do: Wake up in your customized suite to lush tropical views from your private terrace, deck, or garden space before enjoying a free breakfast.

In fact, you can choose from diverse accommodation options, ranging from a suite that provides views of the jungle canopy to a terrace Jacuzzi.

Spend the morning sightseeing with a customized boat tour provided by the resort, or surprise your significant other with a sunset sail.

Other ways to explore the sparkling waters include complimentary kayaks and paddleboards.

For some land exploration, take a bicycle out for a ride.

Unwind with a yoga session or laze by the pool before enjoying a beer tasting.

2. Pines and Palms Resort

Pines and Palms Resort, Islamorada
@Pines & Palms Resort

Rating: 4.4★

Hotel class rating: 3-star

Address: 80401 Old Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036

  • Activity concierge
  • Picnic area
  • Self-service laundry

Why you should go: Discover a home away from home in paradise at Pines and Palms Resort.

The breathtaking destination provides an experience that will allow you to enjoy the natural beauty of Florida to its fullest.

Amenities and things to do: While at the resort, you will find both oceanfront cottages and suites that offer full kitchens for family meals.

Additionally, you can choose to dine outside and cook up some lunch or dinner at your own private grill.

Once you’ve fueled up on breakfast, grab a kayak or paddleboard and enjoy time on the water.

Afterward, go for a bicycle ride, do some fishing off the pier, or unwind with a yoga class.

When you’re ready to cool off, take a dip in the oceanfront pool or go for a swim in the ocean waters.

Also on hand is a boat dock to keep your watercraft and adventure excursions.

Would you like to do some fishing in Islamorada?

At Pines and Palms Resort, you’ll have the opportunity to go on a private fishing expedition with a guide who will ensure you have a fantastic experience doing some deep-sea, reef, or patch fishing, not to mention trying your hand at catching lobster and tarpon.

Moreover, for those who would rather just get an up-close look at marine life, a snorkeling tour is available.

If you’d rather just sit back a relax for the day, head to the beach and get some sun or doze in a hammock.

In the evening, have some drinks at the poolside tiki bar and listen to live music.

3. Cheeca Lodge & Spa

cheeca lodge & spa, Islamorada
@Cheeca Lodge & Spa

Rating: 4.4★

Hotel class rating: 4-star

Address: 81801 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036

  • Boat docking up to 42 feet
  • Golf and tennis instruction
  • Kids’ camp
  • Pet-friendly

Why you should go: Cheeca Lodge & Spa is a luxury resort that provides a relaxing and fun-filled stay.

What’s more, you’ll find pampering services and personalized activities in a classic Florida Keys atmosphere.

Amenities and things to do: Begin your vacation the right way with a visit to the spa for a massage or treatment.

Afterward, swim in the adults-only lap pool or order a drink from your poolside cabana.

Alternatively, you can get a workout at the fitness center, play some ping pong in the game room, or play some tennis.

Other sports and games available at the resort include basketball, shuffleboard, and beach volleyball.

If you’re searching for Islamorada resorts that provide water activities, Cheeca Lodge & Spa has plenty of options.

Glide across the water on a kayak or paddleboard, or try your hand at saltwater fishing.

Golfers will also be pleased with the 9-hole course available, and landlubbers can explore the island by bicycle.

At the end of the day, dine at one of the 3 on-site restaurants before grabbing some drinks at one of the resort’s bars.

Once you’re ready to call it a day, retire to your elegant and spacious accommodations and unwind on the private balcony.

4. The Moorings Village

The Moorings Village, Islamorada
@Source | Rich Estacio

Rating: 4.6★

Hotel class rating: 4-star

Address: 123 Beach Road, Islamorada, FL 33036

  • Kids stay free
  • Massage services
  • Self-service laundry

Why you should go: Located on a former coconut plantation, The Moorings Village is a private beachfront resort that offers seclusion and serenity.

While at the resort, you will be pleased with surroundings that include palm trees, orchids, and lush tropical vegetation.

Amenities and things to do: Take a leisurely stroll along charming pathways to the beach and admire the turquoise waters before going kayaking or paddleboarding.

Afterward, unwind with a dip in the pool, take a bicycle ride, or stop by the fitness center to get a workout.

For lunch, grill up a favorite meal before going on a fly-fishing excursion.

At dinner, you can prepare a meal in your fully equipped kitchen or sample mouthwatering cuisine at Morada Bay.

Return to your cottage at the end of the day and relax in your charming and private space.

5. Islander Resort

Islander Resort, Islamorada
Mia2you | Shutterstock

Rating: 4.5★

Hotel class rating: 3-star

Address: 82100 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036

  • 24-acre property
  • Private cabanas
  • Self-service laundry
  • Pet-friendly

Why you should go: Islander Resort offers the best of both worlds with a tranquil oceanfront property that is conveniently located near numerous local attractions.

Moreover, you’ll find adventure and entertainment both on and off the resort property, plus superb dining options.

Amenities and things to do: Go for a dip in the saltwater or freshwater pool before fueling up with breakfast at Elements Lounge & Restaurant.

Afterward, challenge your friends and family to games like beach volleyball, basketball, or ping pong, as well as shuffleboard.

Soak your muscles in the hot tub, followed by trying your luck at the fishing pier or taking a bicycle ride.

Would you like to find a resort in Islamorada that has daily activities?

Islander Resort provides a multitude of daily entertainment to participate in, such as yoga sessions, card games on the beach, cornhole tournaments, and watersports races, in addition to craft projects, Bingo nights, and sunset cruises.

Furthermore, you can take a paddleboard or kayak out on the water or explore the underwater world while snorkeling.

For dinner, sample fresh seafood at Tides Beachside Bar & Grill before lounging on your private lanai.

6. Pelican Cove Resort & Marina

Pelican Cove Resort & Marina, Islamorada
@Pelican Cove Hotel

Rating: 4.2★

Hotel class rating: 3-star

Address: 84001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036

  • Transportation service
  • Complimentary bicycle
  • Lawn games

Why you should go: Pelican Cove Resort & Marina offers a fantastic getaway destination for water lovers.

In addition to numerous watersports and activities, the resort also provides a laid-back atmosphere and waterfront views.

Amenities and things to do: Spend your days on the water with jet skis, kayaks, stand-up paddleboards, and snorkeling equipment, as well as a nearby scuba diving center.

Also on hand is the unique experience of feeding tarpon from the dock.

For those who are seeking Islamorada resorts with a marina, Pelican Cove Resort is a perfect choice with transient slips, fuel service, and a marina store.

Moreover, if you’d like to do some fishing, the resort offers complimentary fishing classes and access to fishing charters.

At the end of a fun-filled day, sample some casual Floridian fare before returning to unwind on your private balcony.

7. La Siesta Resort & Villas

La Siesta Resort & Villas, Islamorada
@Lasiesta Resort

Rating: 4.2★

Hotel class rating: 3-star

Address: 80241 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036

  • Private marina for small crafts
  • Pet-friendly
  • Lawn games
  • Pool service

Why you should go: Enjoy a vacation that is customized to your desires at La Siesta Resort & Villas.

Particularly, you can choose from accommodations like beachfront cottages, vacation homes, or guest rooms, depending on what type of getaway you are looking for in Islamorada.

Amenities and things to do: While at the resort, you can enjoy a plethora of complimentary watersports rentals.

Explore the Florida Keys’ waters while jet skiing, paddleboarding, or kayaking, as well as snorkeling, diving, and fishing.

Go swimming with dolphins or explore the resort’s sister properties with the use of the complimentary shuttle.

Are you searching for things to do in Islamorada at night?

During your stay at La Siesta Resort & Villas, you can head to Wild & Lime, a colorful oceanside lounge that features live music in addition to superb food, beer, wine, and cocktails, plus a festive tropical atmosphere.

Dolphin lovers gather up here, enjoy interacting with these intelligent creatures by visiting these top places to swim with dolphins in Florida!

8. Drop Anchor Resort & Marina

Drop Anchor Resort & Marina, Islamorada
@Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina, Autograph Collection

Rating: 4.5★

Hotel class rating: 3-star

Address: 84959 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036

  • Private deck or patio
  • Barbecue facilities

Why you should go: A vibrant tropical getaway awaits you at Drop Anchor Resort & Marina.

In addition to providing private docks for boats up to 25 feet in length, the resort has activities both on and off the property you will love.

Amenities and things to do: Head to the beach located right outside your doorstep or take a dip in the pool before exploring nearby attractions.

Particularly, Drop Anchor Resort & Marina is among the resorts in Islamorada that are just steps away from fantastic shopping.

Find bargains, souvenirs, and unique items while perusing the many nearby shops.

Once you’ve had a fun-filled day, return to your coastal-inspired accommodations and fix dinner in your full kitchen.

9. Amara Cay Resort

Amara Cay Resort, Islamorada
@Aber Crombiekent

Rating: 4.4★

Hotel class rating: 3-star

Address: 80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036

  • Private balcony
  • Pet-friendly
  • Transportation service
  • Lawn games

Why you should go: Amara Cay Resort is the perfect destination for a get-together with friends, with a lively atmosphere and casual environment.

Moreover, the resort offers events and activities that will keep you and your group entertained.

Amenities and things to do: Hang out on the private beach or by the pool before heading to the marina for a dolphin tour.

Additionally, you can go snorkeling or tour the Islamorada Sand Bar.

Afterward, grab some drinks at the tiki bar that overlooks the ocean or have an in-room dinner.

Would you like to find some of the best food in Islamorada?

At Amara Cay Resort, you can dine at ReelCatch, a restaurant that serves mouthwatering casual fare, such as Caribbean-inspired dishes, fresh seafood, and a variety of burgers, as well as gourmet cuisine and decadent desserts.

10. Coral Bay Resort

Coral Bay Resort, Islamorada
@Coral Bay Resort

Rating: 4.6★

Address: 75690 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036

  • Full kitchen available
  • Self-service laundry

Why you should go: Be surrounded by the unblemished beauty of the Florida Keys at Coral Bay Resort.

In addition to relaxing amenities, the resort also offers a complimentary boat dock and a private ramp.

Amenities and things to do: Lounge by the heated pool and admire swaying palm trees or take a leisurely stroll among hibiscus and native vegetation.

Spend an afternoon on the beach and fix lunch at the barbecue facilities before hanging out with friends under the tiki.

Lastly, return to your private porch or patio to unwind.

11. Ragged Edge Resort and Marina

Ragged Edge Resort and Marina, Islamorada
@Blue Horizon Windows and Doors LLC

Rating: 4.7★

Hotel class rating: 3-star

Address: 243 Treasure Harbor Drive, Islamorada, FL 33036

  • Private harbor
  • Outdoor pool
  • Self-service laundry

Why you should go: During your stay at Ragged Edge Resort and Marina, you will experience a secluded getaway.

What’s more, the destination is a gem of laid-back Islamorada resorts with a casual atmosphere and thoughtful amenities.

Amenities and things to do: Spend your morning fishing, followed by lunch prepared on the grill.

You can also enjoy activities like bicycling, kayaking, or dozing in a hammock.

Additionally, you’ll find plenty to do just steps from the resort, ranging from eco-tours to beach time.

At the end of the day, retire to tropical-themed accommodations and fix dinner in your kitchenette.

12. Caloosa Cove Resort & Marina

Caloosa Cove Resort & Marina, Islamorada
Don Donelson | Shutterstock

Rating: 4.4★

Hotel class rating: 3-star

Address: 73801 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036

  • Barbecue facilities
  • Sports courts
  • On-site charters

Why you should go: Caloosa Cove Resort & Marina provides an all-encompassing Florida vacation.

Enjoy everything from breathtaking views to classic water and beach activities while at the resort.

Amenities and things to do: Prepare breakfast in your kitchen and dine on your private balcony before taking a dip in the pool.

Would you like to find a full-service marina in Islamorada?

At Caloosa Cove Resort & Marina, you will be pleased with amenities like a fully-enclosed building, a store that carries bait and tackle, slips that provide Wi-Fi, fuel pumps, and electrical hookups, as well as facilities like showers and restrooms.

Additionally, the resort offers the beach right at your doorstep and Cuban-inspired cuisine.