Skip to Content

13 Best Sanibel Island Resorts, Florida (2024 Updated)

Sanibel Island is located off the coast of Florida.

It is home to the small town of Sanibel, where visitors can find a plethora of activities, such as shopping, golf, and local attractions.

Moreover, the little island is an idyllic spot that is a blend of old Florida charm and tropical landscapes.

During your time on the island, you will find watersports, 24 miles of paved bicycle paths, and extraordinary fishing.

Planning to visit other areas of Florida and wondering where to stay? Check out the top Florida’s all inclusive resorts and Florida resorts on the beach to stay in with family & friends.

When you aren’t spending time enjoying recreational activities, visit spots like the 19th-century lighthouse or the boardwalk that will lead you through Florida marshes.

Also on hand are the multitude of beautiful shells along the coastline that wash up from the Gulf of Mexico, making the island a great location for shelling.

Discover more of the top island resorts in the world to find the perfect place to spend your vacation.

To help you find the perfect place to stay during your island getaway, you will find a list below of the best Sanibel Island resorts.

1. Sundial Beach Resort & Spa

Sundial Beach Resort & Spa, Sanibel Island
@Sundial Beach Resort & Spa

Rating: 4.3★

Hotel class rating: 3-star

Address: 1451 Middle Gulf Drive, Sanibel, FL 33957

  • Fitness center
  • Non-motorized watersports equipment
  • 5 swimming pools
  • Recreation staff

Why you should go: You and your family will find a home away from home at Sundial Beach Resort & Spa.

With spacious condominium-style accommodations and conveniences that will keep your vacation worry-free, the resort is a great spot to enjoy an island getaway.

What’s more, the resort prides itself on being family-friendly, with activities for both children and adults.

Amenities and things to do: You’ll spend your days being endlessly entertained at the resort.

Spend the morning playing a game of tennis or pickleball, as well as exploring the island by bicycle.

Particularly, the resort offers complimentary bikes that are suited for both kids and adults.

Moreover, you’ll find a paved trail system along the resort’s property that will lead you to attractions like the Sanibel Lighthouse.

Afterward, enjoy a quick lunch of sushi at Shima Grab N Go.

For afternoon activities, take your kids to the beach and do some shelling or lounge on one of the beach chairs provided.

Alternatively, you can go golfing at the 18-hole course at The Dunes Golf & Tennis Club.

Unwind with a trip to the spa and get a massage while your kids enjoy some fun-filled times at Turtle Scouts Kids Camp.

The camp offers activities like games and crafts in addition to special programs.

Are you looking for adventurous activities on Sanibel Island?

Rent a 3-wheel Polaris Slingshot and have it delivered straight to Sundial Beach Resort to feel the thrill of speeding around the island as you explore beaches, trails, and lush vegetation without worry, as your safety equipment such as helmets is also available.

Comparatively, you can rent a street-legal golf cart to explore the island that seats up to 6 people.

2. West Wind Island Resort

West Wind Island Resort, Sanibel Island
@West Wind Island Resort

Rating: 4.3★

Hotel class rating: 3-star

Address: 3345 W Gulf Drive, Sanibel, FL 33957

  • Pet-friendly
  • Discounts at Captiva Beach Resort properties
  • Kitchenettes available
  • Barbecue facilities

Why you should go: Relax and recharge at West Wind Island Resort, where the beach will be at your doorstep, as well as superb food and warm hospitality.

What’s more, the resort is a great choice for a romantic getaway.

For families, the destination is also a perfect spot to enjoy plenty of recreation and time together.

Amenities and things to do: Wake up and gaze out at the ocean or lush garden from your private patio.

Once you’re ready to get out and explore the resort’s amenities, you’ll have plenty to choose from.

Go paddleboarding on the Gulf waters, take a romantic bicycle ride along beachfront paths, and play some golf.

In particular, West Wind Island Resort is a fantastic choice for those who are seeking resorts in Sanibel Island that offer golf, with discounts at Dunes Golf & Tennis Club for guests of the resort.

Additionally, you can spend your time lounging on the resort’s private beach.

If you’d prefer to explore the island, you’ll find discounts through the resort that allows you to try out a multitude of off-site activities.

Go kayaking, parasailing, or boating, as well as fishing or sampling the various restaurants in the area.

Here are some of the top-rated beach resorts in Captiva Island!

3. Sanibel Moorings Resort

Sanibel Moorings Resort, Sanibel Island
@Sanibel Moorings Resort

Rating: 4.5★

Hotel class rating: 4-star

Address: 845 E Gulf Drive, Sanibel, FL 33957

  • Fitness room
  • Condo-style accommodations
  • Guided garden and beach tours

Why you should go: Covering 6 acres, Sanibel Moorings Resort is the perfect place to experience a tropical oasis.

From lush botanical gardens to a private beach known for its seashells, the resort offers a true island getaway.

Amenities and things to do: Set aside some time to enjoy a leisurely stroll through the resort’s botanical gardens.

While there, you will discover a butterfly garden, a hibiscus collection, and a tranquil fountain.

Moreover, you can grab a book from the resort’s library and spend some quiet time reading in the gardens.

Afterward, challenge your family or friends to a game of tennis or pickleball.

Alternatively, you can lounge by the heated pool while your kids have fun in the children’s pool.

Would you like to find a resort in Sanibel with a marina?

Sanibel Moorings Resort has just what you need with refurbished docks that provide easy access to the Gulf of Mexico and Back Bay while also accommodating boats up to 25 feet and a fantastic spot for fishing.

Once you’ve got your catch of the day, head to the resort’s barbecue facilities and fix a fresh seafood lunch.

4. Tortuga Beach Club Resort

Tortuga Beach Club Resort, Sanibel Island
@Tortuga Beach Club Resort

Rating: 4.8★

Hotel class rating: 4-star

Address: 959 E Gulf Drive, Sanibel, FL 33957

  • Fully equipped kitchens
  • Barbecue facilities
  • Whirlpool

Why you should go: Tortuga Beach Club Resort is an exclusive destination that offers high-end vacation rentals combined with superb amenities and services.

What’s more, you’ll be only a quick stroll from white sand beaches and enjoy complimentary access to nearby recreational attractions.

Amenities and things to do: Begin your day with views of a tropical paradise from your spacious vacation home before heading down to the pool.

While at the lagoon-style pool, you can lounge in the sun before cooling off with a dip.

Also on hand are poolside gazebos for enjoying breakfast or lunch.

Afterward, head to the beach or play some volleyball, pickleball, or shuffleboard.

You can also take advantage of the complimentary greens fees provided by the resort at The Dunes Golf & Tennis Club.

5. Sanibel Inn

Sanibel Inn, Sanibel Island
@The Inns Of Sanibel

Rating: 4.3★

Hotel class rating: 3-star

Address: 937 E Gulf Drive, Sanibel, FL 33957

  • Self-service laundry
  • Sports courts
  • Lawn games

Why you should go: Sanibel Inn is a beachfront resort that has a laid-back and comfortable atmosphere.

A spectacular choice for family-friendly Sanibel Island Resorts, the destination prides itself on offering amenities that will make you feel at home.

Amenities and things to do: Explore the Gule waters by kayak or paddleboard, in addition to renting a boat.

Would you like to go fishing on Sanibel Island?

Sanibel Inn offers a number of ways to catch the variety of species populating the waters around the island with fly fishing, plus onshore and offshore fishing, allowing both novices and expert fishermen to capture redfish, tarpon, and speckled trout, as well as flounder and snook.

Alternatively, you can simply enjoy the view of the Gulf of Mexico as you lounge by one of the pools.

You can also head to the private beach and build some sandcastles with your kids or do some shelling.

Moreover, the resort offers complimentary nature tours your whole family will enjoy.

Looking for more adventure? why not check out the top activities to enjoy in Fort Myers with kids.

Take a bike tour around the island, follow your guide through the waters while kayaking, and learn about the ecosystems around the beaches of Sanibel Island.

Once you’ve had a full day of fun, have a casual family meal before lounging on your private balcony.

6. Island Inn

Island Inn, Sanibel Island
@Island Inn Sanibel

Rating: 4.6★

Hotel class rating: 3-star

Address: 3111 W Gulf Drive, Sanibel, FL 33957

  • No resort fee
  • Complimentary beach accessories
  • Established in 1895

Why you should go: Surround yourself with the unspoiled beauty of Sanibel Island at Island Inn.

Moreover, you’ll be right next to the beach while enjoying modern accommodations.

Amenities and things to do: Wake up in your suite or studio and sip coffee while gazing out at the ocean.

Afterward, hunt for shells on the beach or rent a bicycle to go exploring.

Also on offer at the resort are stand-up paddleboards and kayaks.

Once you and your family are ready for lunch, grill up a meal at the barbecue facilities.

For those who are seeking some adventure, you can book a guided tour of the Gulf.

Take a dolphin-watching cruise or surprise your significant other with a sunset cruise.

Additionally, you can go on a private sailing charter or enjoy some excitement while aboard The Sanibel Thriller.

7. Casa Ybel Beach Resort

Casa Ybel Beach Resort, Sanibel Island
@Source | Beth Wagaman Burgess

Rating: 4.4★

Hotel class rating: 3-star

Address: 2255 W Gulf Drive, Sanibel, FL 33957

  • Fully equipped kitchens
  • 5th night free and no nightly resort fee
  • Award-winning restaurant

Why you should go: Located on 23 acres, Casa Ybel Beach Resort is a luxury destination that combines world-class service and a tropical atmosphere.

Moreover, the resort prides itself on giving guests a laid-back vacation experience.

Amenities and things to do: Begin your vacation the right way with a trip to the resort’s spa.

Get a massage on the beach, in your accommodations, or by the pool.

Comparatively, you can unwind with a facial or body treatment.

Afterward, go for a bike ride and explore Sanibel Island or play some tennis or pickleball.

Also available are sunrise and sunset yoga sessions on the lawn.

If you want to explore the Gulf waters, the resort has plenty of options.

Charter a boat and go sailing, try out so deep-sea fishing or have fun with watersports equipment.

In particular, you can glide across the water on a kayak or paddleboard or feel the thrill of a jet ski.

In the evening, sample tropical flavors by the beach at Thistle Lodge.

While there, you will taste a blend of European and Floridian cuisines.

Once you’re ready for a nightcap, stop by the poolside bar and grill.

Lastly, retire to your suite that is located right by the ocean and lounge on your private balcony or lanai.

8. Waterside Inn on the Beach

Waterside Inn on the Beach, Sanibel Island
@Waterside Inn

Rating: 4.2★

Hotel class rating: 3-star

Address: 3033 W Gulf Drive, Sanibel, FL 33957

  • Fully equipped kitchens
  • Pet-friendly
  • Gift shop

Why you should go: Waterside Inn on the Beach offers unique amenities, such as a private beach, Gulf-front cottages, and at-home conveniences.

What’s more, the resort has a multitude of activities that will keep you and your family entertained.

Amenities and things to do: Unwind with a swim in the resort’s heated pool before playing a game of shuffleboard.

Afterward, rent a bicycle or head to the beach to do some shelling.

While at the barbecue facilities, you can fix a picnic lunch for everyone.

Are you wondering what there is to do on Sanibel Island?

The staff at Waterside Inn on the Beach are always happy to help you find activities in the area, such as planning a visit to the J.N. “Ding” Darling National Wildlife Refuge, the Baily-Matthews Shell Museum, and the Sanibel Lighthouse, just to name a few.

At the end of an adventurous day, return to your bright and airy cottage that exudes a tropical atmosphere.

While there, you can admire views of the Gulf from your private balcony, soak in the Jacuzzi, or make dinner.

Also available are condominiums that provide a screened porch and rooftop sundeck.

9. Song of the Sea

Song of the Sea, Sanibel Island
@Source | Laura Wood

Rating: 4.5★

Hotel class rating: 3-star

Address: 863 E Gulf Drive, Sanibel, FL 33957

  • Kitchens and kitchenettes available
  • Sports courts
  • Barbecue facilities
  • Discount packages available

Why you should go: If you are searching for a romantic destination, Song of the Sea is a resort you won’t want to miss.

The breathtaking property caters to couples and ensures a memorable and intimate getaway.

What’s more, you’ll find activities and amenities that will keep your trip worry-free and relaxed.

Amenities and things to do: Go on a bicycle excursion with your significant other and discover the charming neighborhoods of Sanibel.

In addition to historical sights and local wildlife, you’ll find quaint shops, romantic bridges, and tranquil waterways.

Afterward, play a round at The Dunes Golf & Tennis Club.

As a guest of Song of the Sea, you’ll receive a resort membership to the club, which includes the 18-hole championship course and country club amenities.

In the afternoon, surprise your beloved with a romantic picnic on the private beach before taking a stroll along the shoreline.

Spend time together in one of the heated pools available before trying out some paddleboarding.

Moreover, you can do some fishing or rent a boat for an evening sail.

For some quiet time together, head to the resort’s lawn and play some bocce ball.

Particularly, Song of the Sea is a gem for couples who are searching for romantic resorts in Sanibel Island , with amenities like complimentary wine and private meals.

10. Beachview Cottages

Beachview Cottages, Sanibel Island
@Beachview Cottages

Rating: 4.6★

Hotel class rating: 3-star

Address: 3325 W Gulf Drive, Sanibel, FL 33957

  • Private balcony
  • Pet-friendly

Why you should go: Enjoy a charming vacation experience and a traditional Florida getaway at Beachview Cottages.

In addition to comfortable accommodations, you’ll be delighted with top-tier amenities and services.

Amenities and things to do: Wake up in your Florida-style cottage and take just a few steps from your door to enjoy a morning on the private beach.

Afterward, take a dip in the ocean waters or the resort’s pool.

Also available are canoes, fishing, and hiking trails.

For your evening meal, take advantage of the barbecue facilities or make a favorite dish in your kitchenette.

11. Sanibel Arms West

Sanibel Arms West, Sanibel Island
@Sanibel Arms West Condominium

Rating: 4.6★

Hotel class rating: 3-star

Address: 827 E Gulf Drive, Sanibel, FL 33957

  • Barbecue facilities
  • Rooftop sundeck
  • Business facilities

Why you should go: Sanibel Arms West offers condominium accommodations that are spacious and perfect if you’re in need of Sanibel Island Resorts for an extended stay.

Furthermore, you’ll find plenty of amenities on hand that will keep you entertained and comfortable.

Amenities and things to do: Fix breakfast in your fully equipped kitchen before dining on your private balcony.

Afterward, go for a swim in the heated pool, play pickleball or tennis, and stop by the fitness center.

You can also take a romantic stroll to the beach and lounge by the shore or explore the water.

In particular, you’ll have access to diving, snorkeling, and fishing.

12. Seaside Inn

Seaside Inn, Sanibel Island
@Source | Kate-Doug Marlatt

Rating: 4.5★

Hotel class rating: 3-star

Address: 541 E Gulf Drive, Sanibel, FL 33957

  • Private balconies
  • Kitchens available in cottages
  • Bicycle rental

Why you should go: The Seaside Inn is aptly named, with spectacular views of the water and swaying palm trees lining the property.

Additionally, the resort provides a nostalgic atmosphere with vintage-style accommodations.

Amenities and things to do: Head to the beach and find breathtaking shells along the shoreline before hainge a casual lunch at one of the on-site eateries.

Are you wondering what watersports are available on Sanibel Island?

At Seaside Inn, you can go paddleboarding across the shallow shores or kayak along the waters, as well as go swimming, rent a boat, fish onshore or offshore, as well as go on guided kayaking tours, view dolphins, or learn how to dive.

13. Sanibel Sunset Beach Inn

Sanibel Sunset Beach Inn, Sanibel Island
@The Inns Of Sanibel

Rating: 4★

Hotel class rating: 2-star

Address: 3287 W Gulf Drive, Sanibel, FL 33957

  • Barbecue facilities
  • Private balcony
  • Complimentary breakfast

Why you should go: Sanibel Sunset Beach Inn is a great choice for affordable resorts on Sanibel Island.

In addition to being budget-friendly, the resort offers contemporary coastal décor, warm hospitality, and plenty of activities.

Amenities and things to do: Play a game of tennis or take a bicycle out to explore the island before visiting some of the nearby shops.

Near the resort, you will find outlet stores, boutique shops, and seasonal events like farmers markets.

Alternatively, you can take a dip in the pool or enjoy a picnic.

Visit The Dunes Clubhouse for a resort discount on cocktails and fresh seafood.